The premium hot hatch battle. The BMW M135i xDrive offers an accessible, fast, and surprisingly practical all-wheel drive hatchback. The Mercedes-AMG A45 is a 421hp technical showcase — the most powerful production hot hatch ever built. Both are extraordinary. Both are expensive to own.
The understated choice. The F40 M135i xDrive makes 306hp with intelligent all-wheel drive and near-perfect composure on wet Irish roads. It looks like a normal 1 Series — it is anything but.
The nuclear option. The W177 A45 S with 421hp from a 2.0 four-cylinder is the most powerful production hot hatch in the world. It is violent, extraordinary, and utterly magnificent — but expensive to service and demanding to live with daily.
| Category | BMW M135i | Mercedes-AMG A45 S |
|---|---|---|
| Power output | 306hp | 421hp A45 S ✓ |
| 0–100km/h | 4.8 seconds | 3.9 seconds ✓ |
| AWD system | xDrive — excellent | 4MATIC+ torque vectoring ✓ |
| Reliability | BMW — very good ✓ | AMG — complex |
| Servicing cost | Expensive but predictable ✓ | Very expensive |
| Daily usability | Excellent ✓ | Demanding |
| Stealth factor | Looks standard ✓ | Very obvious |
| Practicality | Large boot, comfortable ✓ | Good but harder ride |
| Irish price range | €28k–€42k ✓ | €38k–€65k |
The F40 M135i is a masterclass in what a premium hot hatch should be. The 2.0 turbocharged B48 engine makes 306hp and delivers it seamlessly through BMW's xDrive system. In wet Irish conditions, the AWD composure is exceptional — no drama, no snap oversteer, just progressive, rapid, confidence-inspiring acceleration. It is fast enough to embarrass most sports cars and refined enough for a Cork to Dublin motorway run in complete comfort.
The key advantage of the M135i over the A45 is livability. BMW's servicing is expensive but predictable. The engine is proven across the 3 Series, 5 Series, and multiple other models. The gearbox is an 8-speed torque converter automatic — smoother and more reliable than most dual-clutch alternatives. For the daily hot hatch that does everything — the M135i is the rational choice.
421hp from a 2.0-litre four-cylinder. That number still stops traffic. The W177 A45 S is AMG engineering at its most extreme — the most powerful engine of its type ever fitted to a production car. The 4MATIC+ torque-vectoring AWD system can send almost all power to the rear axle in drift mode. It is a performance car that happens to have a hatchback body.
The A45 S is also the most demanding car in this comparison to own. AMG servicing is significantly more expensive than BMW. The DCT gearbox requires fluid maintenance. Early W176 A45 models had turbo issues at higher mileage. Buy with full AMG dealer history only — anything less is a false economy at this performance level.
The older W176 AMG A45 (2013–2018) has documented turbo failures at higher mileage (100,000km+). The IHI turbo on these cars is the weak point. Always request a turbo inspection on any W176 A45. The W177 (2019+) uses a completely different twin-scroll turbo system and does not share this issue.
The F40 M135i (2019+) xDrive is the car to buy. The older F20 M135i is rear-wheel drive with a different engine — perfectly good but less polished. The F40's B48 engine and xDrive combination is outstanding. Budget €28,000–€38,000 for a good F40.
Buy W177 (2019+) only if your budget allows. The extra reliability over the W176 justifies the premium. The A45 S with 421hp over the standard A45 with 387hp is worth the additional cost. Budget €42,000–€55,000 for a good W177 example. Full AMG history is non-negotiable.
BMW M135i F40 xDrive — €28,000–€38,000. BMW M135i F20 (older) — €20,000–€28,000. Mercedes-AMG A45 W176 — €25,000–€38,000. Mercedes-AMG A45 W177 — €38,000–€52,000. Mercedes-AMG A45 S W177 — €44,000–€65,000.
The BMW M135i xDrive is the rational premium hot hatch decision. It is fast, refined, practical, and will cost less to own over three years than an A45. The AMG A45 S is the more extraordinary machine — 421hp, torque vectoring, drift mode. If you want the most powerful production hot hatch ever made and will maintain it properly, it is genuinely special. But the M135i is the wiser Irish used car purchase at anything under €40,000.
A Cartell or Motorcheck report costs €10–€15. Hot hatches carry specific risks:
We'll check the history, spec, and market value before you commit to either car.
Get Expert Advice →